top of page

Amber Fortier 

Sacramento Realtor®

Helping you LOVE Where you LIVE

Why I Gave Up My 3% Mortgage Rate (and Why It Was Worth It)

Writer: Amber Fortier
Amber Fortier
Oct 22
4 min read

Updated: Oct 23

Sacramento Realtor Amber Fortier relaxing in her backyard with her dog in her new 55+ active adult community home

“Why would you ever give up a 3% rate?”


I’ve heard that question a lot since we moved. It’s a fair one. So many homeowners feel locked in by the low rates they got a few years ago, and I understand that feeling, because I had one too.


But our home no longer fit our life. Here’s why we made the move, what it cost us, and why we’d do it again.


Why We Left Our 3% Mortgage Rate: We Outgrew Our Home


After Covid, my husband and I both worked from home. I turned a bedroom into my office, and he had a desk behind our couch, next to our pub table. It worked for a while, but it wasn’t going to work long term.


We also needed bigger closets and more room to have people over. The house that once felt like plenty had become a squeeze.


We Were Done With Maintenance and Updates


Our previous home was built in 1994. It wasn’t “old” by most standards, and we had already remodeled much of it, but older homes always need something. We still had a kitchen and a bathroom to fully renovate. The sewer line would need to be replaced at some point because of hard water buildup. And big-ticket items like the water heater, HVAC system, and roof weren’t getting any younger.


We didn’t want to keep pouring money into the house, and as we get older, we wanted a home with less upkeep.


A brand-new home meant no major repairs on the horizon and a lot more peace of mind. Instead of spending money to keep our old home going, we used the equity from it toward our new home, plus landscaping, window treatments, and everything else we needed to settle in. Now we just get to enjoy our home every day, instead of always moving on to the next project or repair.


We Wanted a Better Quality of Life


We were looking for a community with amenities, friendly neighbors, and more opportunities to stay active. In 2025, when my husband turned 55, we moved into a brand-new home in an active adult community.


We planned this move for a couple of years. We toured several new home communities, weighed every cost, and timed it so we could use California’s Prop 19 property tax benefit, which saves us about $2,000 a year. (I broke down the exact math in my Prop 19 blog post.)


Our Dogs Got Their Lives Back


This was a big reason for us.


At our old house, we were attacked by the same loose dog twice. After that, we stopped walking our dogs for almost two years. Cooper became terrified of other dogs, and Jax put on weight, which made her arthritis and torn ACLs even harder on her.


Now they walk twice a day, have a private dog park and dog friends, and Jax moves so much better. Every night we go for a walk as a family and it's become something I look forward to each day. Seeing them happy again has been worth every penny.


We Found Real Community


We lived in our last house for nine years and became friends with just one neighbor.

Today, we know almost everyone. We stop and chat whenever we’re outside, attend social events, spend Sundays at the pool, and have made amazing friends. I didn’t realize how much I’d missed that sense of community until we had it again.


We’re More Active Now


I missed walking my dogs and just stepping outside to enjoy the scenery. Now we have:


  • 5 miles of walking trails

  • A gym with yoga and fitness classes

  • Indoor and outdoor pools

  • Pickleball, bocce ball, horseshoes, and Pool tables

  • A park and a dog park


Low-Maintenance Living Gives Us More Time


With a brand-new home, our to-do list is short: pulling a few weeds and changing HVAC filters. Our yard is smaller and hardscaped, so there’s no mowing. That means more time to actually enjoy where we live.


What Leaving Our 3% Mortgage Rate Cost Us


I want to be honest about the trade-offs, because they’re real:


  • Our mortgage payment doubled - we were paying $1,379 a month

  • We now pay Mello-Roos taxes

  • We have an HOA fee


We knew all of this going in, and we planned for it. For us, the lifestyle upgrade was worth the higher cost. Our last house served its purpose for nine years, but it wasn’t going to carry us into our next chapter.


Should You Give Up Your 3% or Lower Mortgage Rate?


Maybe, maybe not. It depends on your goals, your finances, and how you want to live. A few questions to ask yourself:


  • Does your home still fit your daily life?

  • Are you spending more and more on repairs and updates?

  • Do you feel connected to your neighborhood?

  • Will your home support the next 5 to 10 years of your life?

  • If you’re 55 or older, could Prop 19 make a move more affordable?

  • Can your home accommodate unexpected life changes like illness or an aging parent moving in?


Let’s Talk About Your Options


If your current home isn’t working for you anymore, I’d be happy to walk through your options. If selling doesn’t make sense, I’ll tell you. If it does, I’ll help you build a strategy. I also work with trusted lenders and tax professionals who can help you understand the full financial picture.


Frequently Asked Questions


Is it a mistake to sell a home with a 3% mortgage rate?


Not necessarily. A low rate is valuable, but it’s one factor among many. Space, maintenance costs, location, lifestyle, and long-term plans all matter. Talk with a lender and a tax professional to understand the full cost of moving.


What is an active adult community?


An active adult community is a neighborhood designed for people 55 and older. These communities often include amenities like pools, fitness centers, walking trails, clubs, and social events.


Can Prop 19 help me afford a move in California?


If you’re 55 or older, Prop 19 may let you transfer your property tax base to a new primary residence anywhere in California. Your county assessor can confirm your eligibility.


What extra costs come with new construction communities?


Many newer communities have Mello-Roos taxes and HOA fees. Be sure to factor these into your monthly budget along with your mortgage.


By Amber Fortier, Real Estate Advisor | Nick Sadek Sotheby’s International Realty | DRE #01990796


This post is for general informational purposes and is not intended as a solicitation. Equal Housing Opportunity.

Comments


bottom of page